Stevenson Klotz Law Firm Logo

An Endless Cyle: Trapping People in “The System”

Thursday June 05, 2014 | Category: Civil Rights, Consumer Protection, Criminal, Legal Topics

A growing trend around the country, and especially in Florida, is to jail people who cannot afford to pay fines in criminal cases. As states tighten budgets and courts increasingly become dependent on fines to fund their budgets, states increase the amounts of fines to sustain their operation. These “user fees”┬áseem innocuous enough: if a person commits a crime, he or she should pay for it. However, because courts and court systems depend on these fines, the fines have increased to the point where they are difficult for the middle class to pay and are impossible for those who live in poverty to afford. In the legal world, this phenomenon is referred to as “cash register justice”, and the threat of jail time is used to enforce it. In a country where we pride ourselves on not having debtors prisons, we seem to have lost our way. It is illegal for a consumer collection agency to threaten jail for a consumer debt, but when the government jails people for an inability to pay a fine, we turn a blind eye. States like Florida have become increasingly reliant on fines to finance governmental functions and this system creates a cycle of poverty because the working poor cannot afford to pay the fines, get jailed, and fall even further behind. In some cases, courts suspend people’s licenses for not being able to pay which makes it very difficult to earn a living and pay the fine. This study, The Hidden Costs of Florida’s Justice Fees, makes recommendations that include: exempting indigent defendants from legal financial obligations; allowing payment plans based upon ability to pay; eliminating incarceration for an inability to pay; allowing community service work in lieu of paying fines; and suspending driver’s licenses only when a person has the ability to pay a fine and refuses to do so.

« Back to Posts

We have a 15 Point
Case Assessment Tool

Contact us to schedule your
Free Case Assessment

Hiring a Lawyer?

Downloadable PDF - "10 Things to Consider When Hiring a Attorney" by Stevenson Klotz Law Firm

Instead of just hiring a lawyer from a website or from a billboard, please feel free to download our FREE guide to hiring a lawyer.

Included are questions and information you may simply overlook. Use it to your advantage and find the attorney that is just right for you.

Contact SKLF by calling (850) 444-0000, or...
Email us at Fill out the form below and we will get in touch with you.

I am interested in: